*warning* this is a long entry about complaints.
My complain letter to SMART and LTA:
My friends and I went on board of a SMART taxi, the car plate should be SHB 7120 L, or SHB 7120 K, at Tampines ST 32, opposite Ngee Ann Secondary School, at about 7.00-7.15pm.
We have told the driver to go to Tampines St 11 first, as my boyfriend needs to take his passport, and then followed by Tanah Merah Ferry Terminal.
The driver refused to wait while my boyfriend needed to rush up to his flat for his passport. We have assured him that it will only take less than 5 minutes, and after several persuasion, the driver relented.
Through the journey, the driver keep complaining that he had an experience of waiting for someone to go up to collect his luggage. The passenger also assured him that only 5 minutes is needed, and he ended up waiting for 30 minutes, from a fare of $2.80 to over $10.
He was terribly unhappy, and keep on with his verbal abusement, saying we the youngsters never keep our word, etc etc. We have assured him many times that the longest it would have taken is probably 5 minutes. He raised his voice and told us off, saying that 5 minutes is too long! He will drive off immediately once he felt that he's waiting for too long a time.
Nevertheless, he stopped at Tampines St 11 to allow my boyfriend to rush up to his flat. After waiting for less than 3 minutes, the driver drove off without telling us, while the other 3 of us were still in the cab.
We were shocked! I asked him where he is going to. And again he raised his voice saying he has waited too long, and he will be sending us back to where we boarded.
Just then, my boyfriend called to say that he has reached downstairs only to see the taxi drove away. My friend then tell the driver to turn back, as my boyfriend is already downstairs. The driver refused, continuing to drive off towards Tampines St 32 at a top speed. We again told him to drop us immediately, and he keep on with his verbal abusement and refused to stop.
After the 3 of us keep demanding him to stop, he finally stop at the bus stop near BLK 206 Tampines Ave 2. We were so furious with his attitude! Is this how a taxi driver should behave? It is not as if we will not pay for the fare, and he only waited for less than 3 minutes.
Even if he felt that it's wasting too much time for a 3 minutes wait, he should not drive us away without telling us. He should not refused to drop us immediately and insisted on driving us back to where we boarded the taxi. What is the issue with dropping us immediately and what is the purpose of driving us back to Tampines St 32?
His behaviour deeply affected us and disgust us. There is no reason for him being so rude. If we have made him waited for 30 minutes, I will admit it's our fault. However, it is only less than 3 minutes. Does he have to treat us this way, along with his verbal abusement throughout the journey?
What is worse is that when I told him I lodging a complain against him, he retorted by asking me to go ahead, and telling me his car plate number.
Is this the way your drivers are treating the passengers? I am terribly disappointed and disgusted that even with LTA's campaign and regulations, such taxi drivers still exist!
I can't help but think that since the driver can righteously tell me to go ahead to complain with his car plate number, will the complaints made to your company be taken seriously.
I will be writing to the Press and LTA to conduct an investigation and explanation on the driver's behaviour. This is not the right way to behave, we are all puzzled by his behaviour and convinced that he might not be mentally stabled.
SMART company replied:
Dear Jerlyn Tan,
We regretted on the unpleasant experience that happened to you and your friends at Tampines ST 32, opposite Ngee Ann Secondary School,at about 7.00-7.15pm.
Our company took complaint seriously and will not tolerate errant driver. At the moment we are inquiring into this matter,once we have finalised with our investigate we will keep you posted.
We appreciate your kind understanding and we thank you for your feedback.
Regards,
Ratna
Complaint Officer
Smart Automobile Pte Ltd
Tel : 64857740 /Fax : 64857711
My reply to SMART:
Hi Ratna,
I thank you for your prompt response.
Please note that this experience has deeply disturbed us, and we will be expecting a response from you by the end of this week. We are now considering to take further action on the driver.
I have lodged a complaint regarding this issue to LTA, and has forwarded the email to the Press. If we were not to receive any logical explanation or action taken, I will be escalating to the higher authorities.
Thank You,
Jerlyn
- they have not reply until now.
LTA reply:
Dear Ms Tan
CQ:ATTN: Bus and Taxi Regulation Department (Complaint on SMART taxi)
FEEDBACK NUMBER: 698267
We refer to your email of 15/09/2008.
LTA does not condone any malpractice or misconduct by errant taxi drivers in any incident involving taxi passengers and view all complaints lodged with us seriously. In this respect, we wish to inform you that we will be assigning an Investigation Officer to look into your feedback against the specified taxi.
The investigation officer may contact you for clarifications when necessary. If your case is a straight-forward one where evidence against the errant driver is strong and the facts are not disputed, we will strive to reply within a month from the date we receive your feedback.
However, if the case is more complex, we will need more time to ascertain the intricacies of the case and we seek your understanding that we may take longer than a month to reply to you.
We thank you for writing in.
Yours sincerely
(SIGNED IN LOTUS NOTES)
LIM WAH ERH WILSON
EXECUTIVE SERVICE OFFICER
BUS & TAXI REGULATION
PUBLIC TRANSPORT REGULATION
My reply to LTA:
Hi Wilson,
Thank You for your prompt response.
We are absolutely puzzled and disturbed by the driver's behaviour, and are now considering to take further action on the driver.
We understand that time is needed for an accurate and thorough investigation on this issue. Nevertheless, I hope my friends and I will be able to get a reply as soon as possible, updating us on the progress of the investigation.
Please feel free to contact me if you need further details or information. My friends and I will be more than happy to provide assistance.
Hope to receive your updates soon.
Thanks,
Jerlyn
LTA reply:
Dear Ms Tan,
Please refer to your feedbacks dated 15 September 2008.
We view all complaints lodged with us seriously. We will investigate the complaints thoroughly and fairly. To enable us to do so, we would need to hear from both the complainant and the driver concerned, and secure statements from both parties.
I would appreciate it if you could assist to clarify the following for incident of taxi No.SHB7120K :-
1) What was the date of the incident?
2) How much did you pay for the fare?
3) Are you prepared to give evidence in Court if required by the LTA?
In addition, we also need to have your undertaking to testify in court if required. This is so as we are of the view to issue summons against the errant driver should the case be substantiated.
Your presence in Court may be required if the driver disputes the summons and decides to claim trial. In this regard, we would like to interview and record a statement from you.
We would appreciate it if you could call at our office located at No. 10, Sin Ming Drive, Bus & Taxi Regulation Division (3rd Storey) on 22 September 2008 (Monday) at 03.00pm together with your witness(es), if any.
If you are unable to come on the appointed date and time, please contact me at telephone no. 6553 5804 for an alternative arrangement. If we do not hear from you by 24 September 2008, we will look into it and take necessary departmental action on the matters.
Thank you for bringing the matters to our attention.
Yours sincerely,
LIM LAI HUAT for REGISTRAR OF VEHICLES
My reply to Mr Lim:
Hi Mr Lim,
In reply to your email below,
1) The date of the incident is 12th Sept 08.
2) No, we did not pay for the fare. How can the driver expect us to pay when he did not do his job by driving us to our destination? He even refused to let us alight, which is wrong of him in the first place!
3) Yes, we certainly do not mind if we have to go to Court.
We do understand that LTA and the relevant authorities need to investigate the matter fairly. However, we do not have the time to go down to the office for statement, as all 4 of us have different work schedules and commitments. It is very difficult for us to be able to meet at a single appointed time. We do not mind doing phone interviews. I hope you will understand.
Could you please update us whether has LTA or SMART spoken to the driver? How is the investigation going on? Did the driver admit or dispute against our claims?
If we did not make any statements, how will LTA deal with this issue? Will LTA just close this case and let the driver escape?
Please feel free to contact me at ********, if you need anymore details from my friends and I.
Thank You,
Jerlyn
shortly after my email, Mr Lim called me and explain the need for us to go down to the office for statement. It is for in case the driver dispute against our claims, and they need to go to the Court. Even if we can't go down to the office, they will ask for the driver's statement from the cab company and from there they will conduct the investigation. If we win, the driver is likely to be fined.
He promised to get back to me in a week. So let's see then. If not, I will be forwarding to the press again, stomp, transport minister (which dom so kindly provide me with the email address).
i am currently thinking what should I reply to the SMART company.. let me post again when I have got any idea.
Jerlyn Liselle
|